Six Degrees of Separation … in December

‘On the first Saturday of every month, a book is chosen as a starting point and linked to six other books to form a chain. Readers and bloggers are invited to join in by creating their own ‘chain’ leading from the selected book.

Six Degrees of Separation: Kate W

This month’s chain began with Edith Wharton’s Ethan Frome, which I’m so glad to have read. Bookish Beck has written a wonderful review of it, which I can’t improve on. Read it here.

Here is a man, Ethan Frome, whose life has not gone according to plan. Javier Cercas, in Lord of All the Dead tells us about another such life, that of Manuel Mena. If you’re a left-leaning writer it’s a bit of an embarrassment to discover, as Javier Cercas did, that your ancestor died fighting for Franco in the Spanish Civil War. And yet, unless he follows the story through soon, he realises that the few remaining people who knew Manuel Mena would be dead. And he uncovers a history in which a boy from a backward and poor village in Extremadura, through hard work and determination seems ready to reinvent himself and prosper because of his brains and his schooling. Then he decides to fight for Franco. Cercas discovers, in this account of a brutal civil war that all is not as black and white as it at first appeared, that Mena isn’t necessarily someone for whom he can continue to feel moral superiority. An uncomfortable and thought-provoking read.

Spanish Republican POW’s interned in Le Vernet, France. You can read about our visit here

From one war to another. Not combat this time, but life as a POW in WWII. Midge Gillies‘s Barbed Wire University: the Real Lives of Prisoners of War in the Second World War. This was a fascinating read, and Gillies’ own father was a POW, so she’s able to describe his own experiences too. This is an account of the lives of the prisoners, mainly from Germany, Italy and the Far East, and from the officer classes. These men had more leisure time (aka stretches of boredom, without the resources in some cases to do much to relieve it) and therefore left more in the ways of letters and diaries than those working POWs in the ranks. The horrifying differences between the experiences of those incarcerated in Europe, compared with their fellow combatants in the Far East is fully explored. This is a lively account, relying on the diaries, reminiscences and letters of those who spent their war years largely locked up. The skills the men developed which informed their – often highly successful – later careers are quite astonishing in their breadth and depth. The book rightly concentrates on the humdrum daily life of the majority. This is not the book in which to find accounts of daring escapes or would-be escapes. I was left impressed by the resilience, ingenuity and dogged persistence of the POWs whose war time years must have been in different ways as difficult as that of many combatants.

The POWs ‘experiences were not those of the inmates of Auschwitz, where this image comes from. but the watch towers, the fencing would be familiar.

From one type of prison to another: a fictional women’s prison, allegedly situated some miles from my home in Ripon. A Murder Inside, by Frances Brody. We meet a committed new governor, a body in the grounds, a missing prisoner, and a cast obviously destined to appear again in subsequent books in the series..  An enjoyable enough read, but this doesn’t come high on my list of must-reads.

The countryside between Harrogate and Ripon, where this story is located.

A virtual prison this time: that of loneliness. Gail Honneyman‘s Eleanor Oliphant is Completely Fine. I’m always wary of much-hyped books, and in this case, my wariness wasn’t misplaced. Socially awkward Eleanor is bright, in a job that demands too little of her, and she is totally without friends. Her story, and her back-story slowly come to light. And things start to get better for her, thanks to an unlikely friendship which precipitates a chain of events, such that she is in danger of living happily ever after by the end of the book. I didn’t believe in her, not really. I don’t believe she could have grown up in the circumstances life threw at her quite so unaware of the 21st century. Still, I read it easily enough, and it wasn’t a bad story. Read it on a train journey, maybe.

Office life for Eleanor? (Bernard Hermant, Unsplash)

And here’s another book in a similar vein. A Man called Ove by Frederik Backman. I took against this book in the first few pages. It was obvious that the story line was going to be ‘curmudgeonly old man, widely disliked, is revealed to have a heart of gold, and after about 250 pages, everyone lives happily ever after’. This is exactly what happened. I turned the pages readily enough, but was unconvinced by almost everyone but the cat. I didn’t believe in his friendly new neighbour, or his wife, or another neighbour, Rune. But most of all, I didn’t believe that Ove would turn from irritable and irritating to everyone’s favourite grandfather in the space of about three weeks. Read this one on the train too.

Ove? (GLady, Pixabay)

My last book links not so much to Ove, as to Ethan: but all three books have male heroes. The Invisible Bridge by Julie Orringer. Simon Scharma observes, on the cover of the edition I read ‘You don’t so much read it as live it’. It’s true. This is an immersive story, mainly set between about 1937 and 1945, about a Hungarian Jew, Andras, who spends time in Paris as a young architecture student, and meets the slightly older Hungarian widow who will become the love of his life. The story follows him as he returns home, and as Hungary becomes ever more implicated in the war. The story of the Jewish population in Hungary isn’t well known in the UK. It’s clear that while they were not on the whole sent to concentration camps, their conditions in the Labour Corps of the army – all that was open to Jewish men – were no better. I couldn’t leave this book till I had finished it. It’s well written, and beautifully researched, though Orringer wears her learning lightly. I’ll read more of her work.

Next month, our chain-beginner is another American writer, Amor Towles: Rules of Civility. I know neither the book, nor the author. Another discovery, courtesy of Six Degrees.

Author: margaret21

I'm retired and living in North Yorkshire, where I walk as often as I can, write, volunteer, and travel as often as I can.

51 thoughts on “Six Degrees of Separation … in December”

  1. I’ve read Eleanor too. I’d like to read your last one and the Spanish Civil War story. The others, not so much. Have you written, or are you writing, a book, Margaret? You write succinctly and very well. Wishing you a happy weekend!


    1. Thanks Jo. That’s a lovely compliment coming from my blogging friend who writes so well herself. I think you’d like Julie Orringer’s books. I do. Happy Saturday!


  2. I began but did not finish Eleanor Oliphant. Next month’s starting book is wonderful, as is Towles second novel. I haven’t come to the top of the library list yet to read his newest.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I adore Ove (I’m Norwegian and he reminds me of a few relatives!) and I love brave Eleanor! But I fall hard for quirky characters!

    I think your chain is brilliant! 🙌

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Great chain! The only one of those I’ve read (apart from Ethan Frome) is The Invisible Bridge, which I found fascinating as I previously knew so little about Hungary’s part in the war.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Lord of All the Dead interests me. I don’t know enough about the Spanish Civil War, only Hemingway’s version of it.

    The Invisible Bridge also interests me, because I researched a Hungarian film director a couple of years ago, Alexander Esway, a contemporary of Alexander Korda, so know that Hungarian Jews had a differently difficult interwar experience.

    I got a lot out of Eleanor Oliphant is Completely Fine. I found it an interesting character study, and it got me thinking about the cruelty of modern society and how someone like Eleanor might end up so disconnected from it.

    I haven’t read A Man Called Ove, but I enjoyed the film. I didn’t know it was based on a book.

    I rate next month’s starting book very highly.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. And I didn’t know Ove had ben made into a film. That would work well, I think. I felt Eleanor’s story was an interesting one. But that it became resolved so relatively quickly was what unsettled me. But judging by the kind of book you recommend, I think we’ll be able to agree on our thoughts on The Invisible Bridge.


      1. The actor who played Ove was very good. Sometimes a story needs someone to put flesh on its bones. I don’t think I’ll read the book to find out, though!

        I had my moment of feeling unsettled at the start of Eleanor Oliphant. I feared that it was going to be a tale where Eleanor was simply the butt of a mean joke, and appreciated it when it turned out to be more nuanced than that.

        I’ve reserved The Invisible Bridge at the library. It will slot in nicely on my tour of Europe.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Eleanor seemed to me to be a reasonably good book, out of which a very good one was struggling to come out. I just felt her lifelong-difficulties were resolved too quickly and glibly. Ah well. I hope we agree on The Invisible Bridge. I think we might.


  6. Great chain Margaret! The Invisible Bridge sounds really interesting and educational. I’ve enjoyed both Ove and Eleanor, but I fully appreciate they can’t be to everyone’s taste.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Well, hooray for being a library volunteer then. The Invisible Bridge was a book I didn’t know, though I’d heard of Orringer. So I decided not to shelve it, but to bring it home instead. I’ve had a few wins that way.


  7. Isn’t it interesting how one book can send all of us off in so many different directions? I’d never have thought of the one you’ve followed, and it works so well!

    I’m very glad not everyone likes Eleanor Oliphant. It was so hyped that I just could not bring myself to read it – I frequently feel like this about books that are pushed and pushed, but then I wonder if maybe I’m just shooting myself in the foot. It’s the same with Ove – my son has recommended it to me many times, but I know I’m resisting. The two of us each sent the other six books last year, and I was surprised by how many of his choices I ended up enjoying – whether or not that’s enough to make me read Ove though is another question.

    Lord of All the Dead and Barbed Wire University both interest me. I’d like to know more about the Spanish Civil War – I’ve only read about it in Jessica Mitford’s autobiography (a very brief mention) and in a not-very-good detective novel set mainly in Gibraltar. I don’t think I can face Hemingway! So this could be a better option. And I know so little about Prisoners of War.

    So thank you for some great recommendations.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you for your lovely, and interesting comments. I hope you’ll manage to find Lord of the Dead. It’s an involving read. And let’s see whether your son persuades you to read Ove!


  8. Oh my greatness Margaret! What a brilliant chain. I especially enjoyed how you got to Eleanor Oliphant and A man called Ove.

    And your photos are beautiful.

    Hope you are well and Season Greetings!

    Elza Reads

    Liked by 1 person

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: